No to war in Ukraine

UCU Left would like to encourage supporters to express their opinions on how trade unionists should respond to the war in Ukraine. Sean Vernell, writing in a personal capacity, kicks off the discussion.

President Putin’s decision to send Russian troops into Ukraine after recognising two areas in Eastern Ukraine is a terrifying act of imperialist aggression. Images of ordinary people fleeing for their lives as bombs explode in their cities is a heart-breaking spectacle.

The announcement by Putin to put nuclear forces on alert is chilling and illustrates the danger to the world.

It should fill us with rage and motivate us to campaign to demand Russian troops be withdrawn and open our boarders to Ukrainian refugees.

But our rage should not stop there. We should also tell our leaders and their NATO allies to stop meddling in other countries affairs. The attempt by NATO and western leaders to portray this fight as one between democratic nations and tyrannies is wrong.

Of course, we have been here before. Blair and Bush tried to justify their wars in the middle east on the basis of the need to defeat Saddam Hussein – the ‘new Hitler’, to protect women’s rights in Afghanistan or the ‘humanitarian bombing’ of Kosovo – all in the name of freedom and democracy.

This war is not between mighty Russia and the Ukraine. Ukraine is a pawn in a much wider global military and economic rivalry between two different power blocks. On the one side stands Russia and China. On the other side the NATO forces, 30 nations including US and Britain.

NATO, set up during the cold war to pursue the interests of western powers in eastern Europe, ever since the fall of the Berlin wall has maneuvered to increase its spheres of influence in eastern Europe. The lucrative gas and oil fields are once again a key determining factor that motivates their operations.

Our leaders like to portray Putin’s actions as that of a ‘madman who has lost his marbles. But Putin’s actions are not the result of ‘irrationality’.

Putin has made a brutal decision to challenge the West and the post-Cold War order, which has seen the West and NATO expand their influence Eastwards. His use of the Russian military to invade Ukraine is an attempt to discipline ‘near abroad’, to quieten domestic critics and make moves to restore Russia’s sphere of influence from the past.

Putin is a ruthless and an authoritarian leader who has more in common with Tsarism than he does with Lenin and Bolsheviks who set up the Baku conference in 1921 to recognise national independence.

Putin’s decision to enter the Ukraine is based upon an assessment that the US and NATO are weak and divided.  The key power, the US, is no longer the power it once was. The US’s recent defeat and withdrawal from Afghanistan is just the most recent example of this weakening power and influence in key regions of the world.

Britain no longer has an empire. But the Tory party believe that they still are an important world military power. The ridiculous rant made by defence secretary Ben Wallace to rally the troops about how the Scots guards ‘kicked Tsar Nicholas I’s arse’ in the Crimea in 1853 ‘and we will do it again’ is a reflection of how out of touch our political leaders are with reality.

European powers are increasingly divided over how best to maintain economic growth and stability as the rows over Brexit demonstrate.

Putin’s assessment of the weakness of his enemies has driven him to seize his moment. It is an attempt to finish the prolonged war of attrition between Russian and the West since the collapse of the USSR on his terms.

It is down to Russian workers to prevent Putin sending their sons and daughters to die on the battlefields of the Ukraine. The brave anti-war demonstrations that have taken place in 40 cities across Russia are ones that we must do all we can to support.

The response of our leaders to the Russian invasion of the Ukraine will fundamentally determine how far this crisis in the Ukraine will escalate and therefore how many lives are lost to maintain their power base within eastern Europe.

It is our responsibility to do all we can to prevent our government taking decisions that will lead to tens of thousands of ordinary working men and women to losing their lives, not for democracy or liberty but for gas lines and spheres of influences which enrich the lives of the already rich and powerful.

Wars are fought not by the sons and daughter of the wealthy. It is the poor and unemployed of one country killing and maiming the poor and unemployed of another.

This is why, although not surprising, it is a disgrace that Sir Keir Stammer, the leader of the opposition, is attempting to out warmonger Johnson. It is quite pathetic to watch Starmer berate Johnson for not being more assertive in his actions against Russia.

A man who only a few years ago marched with us on the streets of London to oppose Bush and Blair’s wars in the middle east. Starmer is a pure opportunist. He has no principles. For him it’s all about getting elected. He believes that by trying to out warmonger Johnson he will win a few votes and demonstrate to the rich and powerful that he can be trusted more than Johnson to protect and run the British state and further NATO’s disastrous imperial strategy. Even if this means tens of thousands dying to do so.

Once again it will take working class solidarity to prevent the warmongers making our children pay for their greed.

Sean Vernell NEC (PC)

One Reply to “No to war in Ukraine”

  1. The invasion of Ukraine is a completely unjustified assault on the sovereignty and independence of the people of Ukraine, a return to the Great Russian chauvinism of the Tsars and Joseph Stalin. All Russian troops should immediately withdraw from Ukraine.
    Ukraine has the right of self-defence.
    Thousands of Russian citizens have taken to the streets to protest and have been brutalised and arrested by Putin’s police. They deserve our full support and solidarity.
    The war in Ukraine is a product of the rivalry between two imperialist camps over which set of exploiters gets to rule in Ukraine.
    The support given to Ukraine by the NATO governments is not disinterested support for democracy, rather an escalation of the conflict between Russian and US imperialism. A “no-fly zone” over Ukraine could lead straight to a war between the two imperialist powers.
    The Ukrainian resistance will be making a mistake if they think that NATO will give them real independence and democracy. The Kurds trusted NATO and were betrayed once their usefulness to NATO was over.
    NATO is not a defensive alliance; it is an instrument of US, UK and EU imperialism, which dismembered Yugoslavia, devastated Iraq and destroyed Afghanistan.
    The UK should open the borders and offer full citizenship rights for Ukrainian refugees. Another reason to oppose the Nationality and Borders Bill. As in Germany, when they let in the refugees a few years ago, this would give a boost to extreme right-wing racism. So be it. The one thing the working class movement in Britain has been reasonably good at is fighting fascism. The sooner we take them on, the better. We will only empower them by compromising.
    No confidence in our rulers to defend democracy at home or anywhere else. This is all happening at the same time as the Police and Courts Bill.
    Sanctions can be as devastating on the ordinary people as a bombing raid – thousands in Iraq went to an early grave as a result of not enough to eat and lack of medicines. The US blockade of Cuba has been devastating.
    Sanctions are war by other means. Given the nature of capitalist society, the idea of “Targeted Sanctions” is a farce. The rich still get richer, while the poor get very much poorer, because the scarcity of supplies leads to a black market, which requires large amounts of capital. The bourgeoisie, who, because of sanctions, cannot make money in their normal way, invest in the black market and make up for their losses at the expense of the people.
    It would be a blow against imperialism if the Russian army was defeated by the Ukrainian resistance.
    Resistance to the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan was an important step in the eventual collapse of the Warsaw Pact bloc. So may it be for today’s Russian imperialism. Equally, NATO left Afghanistan and Iraq with their tails between their legs.
    The key to the defeat of Russian imperialism is in the mass movement that appears to be developing against the war in Russia itself. Equally, the Russian Army already appears to be demoralised. Just as the combination of the Vietnamese armed resistance, the disaffection of the troops in the US army, the anti-war protests in the USA itself and worldwide solidarity caused the US defeat in Vietnam, a similar alliance could defeat the Russian oligarchy without further empowering NATO imperialism.
    Meanwhile, some slogans:
    Welcome the Ukrainian refugees
    Russian Troops out of Ukraine
    Solidarity with the Russian anti-war movement.
    Support the Ukrainian resistance
    No NATO intervention
    Neither Washington not Moscow, but International Socialism
    Let us not forget the murderous assault on Yemen by the Saudi airforce.
    Saudi Arabia out of Yemen
    No arms supplies to the Saudi government

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.