Report on Special HE Sector Conference on SoS Dispute, 14 October 2026

This was a half-day online special Sector Conference called as the result of over 20 branches passing motions which was limited to discussing the ‘Secretary of State Dispute’ (‘SoS Dispute’), working with the NEU and other unions, and improving electronic balloting. In the end only motions on the first of these were timetabled.

Unusually, this meant three motions debated over the course of more than three hours, which at least allowed for a proper debate.

This report is both a summary of the debate and an attempt to explore these positions. It is also necessary to comment on the fact that the union’s Higher Education Committee (HEC) is split: there is a very clear section of the HEC (the “UCU Commons” and “Independent Broad Left/CUD” factions) which does not want the union to take industrial action, and a left wing (UCU Left and other independent left reps) that is continually trying to find ways to rebuild the fight against job and pay cuts. Unfortunately, the HEC is now dominated by the former group.

The motions and the debate

Motion 1 sought to open a Secretary of State dispute over HE funding and run a consultative ballot of members; whereas Motion 2 basically called for all work on it to stop. Motion 3 argued to build political and industrial campaign over pay and jobs in conjunction with the Secretary of State dispute. (The Second Report of CBC contains the motion text.)

The debate was organised in two parts: the first part concerned Motions 1 and 2, which were in opposition; the second part concerned Motion 3.

The Secretary of State dispute is a plan supported at two annual Sector Conferences in 2025 and 2026. Different legal advice has been sought by proponents of this campaign and by the union on the potential for such a dispute. Both envisage such a dispute begins as an industrial dispute with the employers that cannot be resolved by their actions alone, rather than a standalone dispute.

Motions 1 and 2

The first debate was remarkable in that on the one hand those opposed to taking it forward made apocalyptic claims about the consequences for the union if it were progressed, but in the end the vote was overwhelmingly in favour of Motion 1 (Motion 2 fell as a result)!

Before the debate began, delegates were told it was an “unworkable” campaign. On the contrary, advocates argued, they were outlining a new approach openly addressing the funding crisis in the marketized system. They said this approach should be tried in full, and that it would galvanise disillusioned members exhausted from local disputes. Their opponents referred to legal advice solicited by the union that this will be presented as a political campaign and would be ruled unlawful. Some speakers argued against on the basis it is relevant only to England, possibly by extension to Northern Ireland (with different industrial relations legislation). Proponents argued the Barnett formula would mean funds would reach devolved nations and regions if English spending increased.

The demand relating to “funding” resolved into a call to increase direct grants to universities available to the Secretary of State for Education in England. Other interventions, such as challenges to tuition fee mechanisms or demands related to overseas students would be “political” and ruled out.

A number of alarmist and absurd arguments were wheeled out by some speakers from the UCU Commons and Independent Broad Left factions to challenge this proposal. They claimed (wrongly) it would prevent local trades disputes over jobs, pensions or terms and conditions. Some even claimed members would be committing criminal acts, which is plainly false. The motion did not even call on the union to challenge the anti-union laws (which is civil law).

Indeed, Motion 3, which sought to take forward Motions HE11A.1 and B27 from the last Sector Conference, was not in competition with Motion 1 (see below). It is entirely possible to run a serious industrial campaign to defend jobs or fight for pay or pensions while putting pressure on the Secretary of State for Education in England (among others) to demand they use their offices to help resolve the dispute.

The debate on Motion 2 was taken at the same time. Motion 2 essentially said “let’s do nothing until the legal advice is more favourable.” The debate to move this was unconvincing; doing nothing offers no hope to members, leaves them as passive spectators, and will not help with the HEC majority’s desired density-building campaign.

Despite clear opposition from the President and the Head of Collective Bargaining, and even scaremongering about the risk to members of jail time (!) from speakers against, Motion 1 passed easily (votes for: 101, with 25 against, 18 abstentions). An amendment to extend the campaign to workers in private HE providers carried.

Motion 3

The debate then moved to Motion 3, which called for an urgent industrial and political strategy to save jobs across the sector. Two motions calling for this had also passed at HESC 2026 (HE11 after amendment, and, in more detail, B27).

Since Autumn 2023, the employers have been on the offensive against HE staff, and they have made mass redundancies the principal way of breaking the resolve of the union. That offensive has spread from redundancies to more diverse attacks: outsourcing, attacks on pensions and derecognition. The absence of a UK-wide fightback has meant that the employers pick and choose which branches to attack, and when. The result has been disastrous for the union.

This is the same prospectus that has motivated colleagues who proposed the Secretary of State dispute plan. But there are simpler ways of getting back to UK-wide action.

The first method is a UK-wide dispute over pay with the employers via the JNCHES negotiating machinery. This is the most direct route. However, a pay campaign appears not to fit the political situation when the sector is suffering so many redundancies. And the last pay action we took was sabotaged by members of the Commons and IBL factions on the HEC who blocked the reballot of members during the MAB in the summer of 2023 agreed by the earlier HESC.

The second method has not been tried by UCU, although it is similar to the #CoronaContract demand from 2020-21.

This is to run a sector-wide industrial campaign over redundancies. The legal mechanism involves going into dispute with each employer on a disaggregated basis. Employers would be served letters calling on them to guarantee no compulsory redundancies for a year, the duration of the coverage of the ballot. (Other local demands might be added.) If an employer refused, action could be taken alongside other branches, even if the employer had not produced a specific proposal for redundancies at the time.

If an employer agreed to commit to no redundancies, members in that branch would not be able to take part in the strike action. But if they later reneged on this commitment, then they could. This is a well-understood legally sound strategy which ‘inoculates’ branches against redundancies.

As speakers for Motion 3 pointed out, such a strategy would be “like a fist in the glove” of the Secretary of State dispute. It starts with what we are fighting for – a concrete demand of a moratorium on job losses and other attacks. The Secretary of State dispute then becomes realised in practical terms: a call on government to bail out universities to stop redundancies.

It was argued by several speakers that combining Motions 1 and 3 would allow for local defence of terms and conditions alongside a national dispute over funding. A friendly proposal to take Motion 3 in parts from supporters removed some tricky time constraints to make it easier to implement. An amendment to include workers in private providers similar to that for Motion 1 again passed.

Perhaps surprisingly, some of those who supported Motion 1 opposed Motion 3. The main argument appeared to be that they wanted a Secretary of State dispute without any other national dispute alongside it. This seems strange, as the legal advice they had sought did not support this type of dispute. UK law does not readily allow employees of universities to strike against the government. Even schoolteachers directly employed by local authorities had to reach the limit of their trades dispute with the employers before they could turn to intervention from the Secretary of State. And universities are specifically ‘autonomous’ from the government according to the law.

A second argument was that ‘we had tried and failed to get a ballot for’ UK-wide action over redundancies. This is not correct. The strategy of a disaggregated dispute over redundancies has not been tried by UCU. We have had a recent consultative ballot over pay, which was in favour of industrial action, albeit on a 30% turnout.

Crucially, without an industrial campaign to fight for members right now, we leave our members open to employer attacks. Instead of focusing members on the prospects for government intervention, branches will be forced to focus on defending themselves from their employers. This is the same strategy that has failed over the last three years.

Unfortunately, the speakers against from the pro-SoS dispute campaign led to a tied vote (64 for, 64 against, 9 abstentions). This meant that Motion 3 was not carried, which was a shame, as the HEC needs continuous pressure from the rank and file of the union.

In fact, the policy position remains from motions HE11 and B27 at HESC. (Not passing a motion is not the same as passing a motion directing the union to do the opposite.) These motions need to be followed up: we cannot wait for employers to go on the attack.

Equality and inclusion

The online voting platform used for the SHESC, run by CES, required intensive screen use but it does record voting results. Those who wished to speak for and against motions or to raise procedural motions had to submit requests in advance. There were complaints from some disabled delegates about the accessibility of the platform. 

What will the HEC do with the decision?

A big factor framing the debate was the question whether or not the HEC, with a Commons/IBL majority, will implement motions passed by HESC (including the Special HESC). The debate was at least refreshing in exposing the attitude of leading members of these factions, who spoke against Motions 1 and 3, rather than advocating ways they might be implemented.

But now that Motion 1 is in their hands, will it be implemented?

Speakers from the floor talked about a widespread perception of low confidence in the central union. This is very dangerous for a union, especially one under attack like UCU is right now.

The solution is to go back to basics: Central union figures (including the General Secretary) need to go out on the ‘stump’ to show that they do want to give a lead to members who want to fight.

Branches that are moving into dispute and those on strike should be supported 100%. And HEC officers should be going around other branches arguing how the union will fight back to defend jobs in the sector and building solidarity.

If UNITE can support the ICR strikers on all-out indefinite strike and give them strike pay for each day of strike, why can’t UCU do the same for Goldsmiths?

Transparency over voting records on HEC would bring some accountability to our elected representatives. But the truth is the left is in a minority on the HEC. UCU Left members will demand that HEC reconvene to move the Secretary of State campaign onwards, but given the speeches from the Commons/IBL at the Sector Conference, and in the absence of the launching of a concrete fight over jobs or pay to give the Secretary of State dispute traction, we are not hopeful.

The way to really shift the union to the left is to build the fightback and solidarity in branches, and use the forthcoming elections to increase the number of serious left activists with a track record of leading in their branches on the HEC.


Postscript

This report was written shortly after the HESC and embargoed to allow the HEC to decide what its next steps would be. UCU Left members argued for a Special HEC to take forward the Conference decision. Unfortunately, the majority of the HEC voted for a proposal from the Chair to not take Motion 1 forward but instead to reconstitute the Secretary of State Dispute working group, inviting members from branches which passed the calling motion to attend a meeting to discuss the next steps, possibly asking for more legal advice.

This reverts the union to its position prior to the HE Sector Conference in Harrogate.