Members who have attended Congress in the last few years should have received an invitation to complete this survey, which was issued in the name of the President, Dyfrig Jones by email to delegates on 16 October.
Below we discuss this survey and make some recommendations about how delegates could usefully respond.
Congress and the two Sector Conferences are the supreme decision-making bodies of the union. It is always wise to investigate how they are working and how we might improve and strengthen our democracy. Indeed, UCU set up a Democracy Commission in 2018 after Congress was suspended by a walkout of officials seeking to protect the then General Secretary from a motion of no confidence (picture above). That commission looked at a series of questions to improve democracy. None of the proposals in this survey overlap with those.
This survey is loaded and clumsy. It asks for colleagues’ opinions on questions without identifying the problems that they seek to solve.
As we shall see, one question about allowing the union to change its rules by e-vote of members rather than by the present process (motions and amendments, debate at the AGM (Congress) and a two-thirds majority vote) is profoundly undemocratic. You don’t need to be a political scientist to realise that this question alone raises questions about the motives behind this survey.
This survey cannot decide anything, but it does canvass support for propositions that the current Right-dominated NEC would likely try to implement through proposed rules changes at next year’s Congress.
Any proposals would need to be proposed as “Rule Change Motions” to Congress and get a two thirds majority. The same applies to Congress Standing Orders.
The first four questions on this survey ask about the sector you are in, how often and how you have attended Congress.
Question 5, on being open to reassessing how votes are taken at Congress, makes the suggestion that votes are not taken if there are no speeches against.
We would strongly suggest responding ‘no’ here. Sometimes motions without opposing speeches are voted down. Instituting such a rule will force people to oppose motions, so it may slow down Congress! Sometimes people can feel intimidated in speaking against a popular motion but point out a fundamental flaw in it which can win over the conference floor.
Question 6, on being able to amend the agenda, is presented in a somewhat distorted way which exaggerates the amount of time lost as a result of challenges to the agenda presented by the Congress Business Committee (CBC). With great respect for all the work of CBC, the right to challenge the agenda is an important part of our democracy. CBC has to follow the rules, whereas delegates can be more lenient on, for instance, accepting the reasons a motion was submitted late or the motion being in order. New information may come to light. Additional information for delegates might also reduce the number of challenges without negatively affecting democracy. We also note that the suggestions are biased in favour or reducing delegates’ control over the agenda, and none would increase it. We therefore encourage you not to tick any of the proposed options.
Question 7 suggests that rules may be amended by e-ballot without a Congress debate. This is an extremely dangerous idea. It is also shockingly naive.
The rulebook is the set of principles that govern the trade union.
Changing a rule should be done very very carefully, and debate at Congresses is essential. You only have to think what an e-voting process might mean for union democracy and structures were we facing an aggressively hostile far-right Trumpite/Farage government making propaganda against trade unions. The rules are what help branches hold the centre accountable. If they have defects they should be improved, but via existing democratic mechanisms.
The first thing that would be lost by an e-ballot process is opportunity for meaningful democratic debate. Currently, rule changes must be circulated months in advance of Congress. Branches can then debate proposals, put forward amendments and elect and instruct delegates on which way to vote (termed ‘mandating’). Then at Congress, all delegates get to hear arguments brought forward by delegates, and finally vote, where a two-thirds majority is needed to change the status quo. This process is deliberately conservative, because changing the rules of a trade union is like ‘rewiring’ it.
Rule change motions are also involved in changing standing orders, Model Local Rules, equality strands, specialist groups, and Regions and Nations. So were this proposal passed, your branch could have its rules unilaterally changed by an e-ballot of all members.
Even where a rule change is relatively innocuous, debate is essential to allow implications to be identified and explored, which is often not clear from the wording.
By contrast with the existing process, an e-ballot of members concentrates power in the hands of those posing the question on the ballot paper (like this survey).
That is why the UK Electoral Commission exists to decide questions on referendum ballot papers independently from Parliament, setting out sufficient timescales and ‘equal campaigning’ principles! The only answer that should be given here is ‘no’!
Question 8 proposes increasing the majority for overturning Chair’s decisions to two-thirds. Chairs work hard to get through all the business while allowing debate. To do this they should rule with the tacit agreement of the Congress floor and avoid making unnecessary decisions which might trigger a challenge. There is no good reason for changing the vote from simple majority, so we would recommend colleagues put ‘no’.
Question 9, on NEC deciding how time is allocated, is odd. Part of the stated motivation of the survey was that motions were falling off the agenda. So why is this question being put? The solution to this is not to suggest that time is taken away from motions and used for other activities! This will lead to even more motions being timed out. NEC currently does not have a role in deciding the Congress agenda (this is CBC’s role) and we should not be increasing its power in this way.
It is also not a well phrased question. For instance, there are currently no panel discussions, only fringe meetings, some of which may be panel discussions. None of these non-resolutionary discussions should supplant the central democratic function of Congress.
Congress and the Sector Conferences are the main decision-making bodies of the union. They should prioritise motions: other activities may be organised round them. This does not mean we do not recognise the value of networking with other members and discussing wider topics. We therefore, propose you mark “a lot more time” for the debate of motions, “about the same” for fringe meetings and social events and do not mark anything for panel discussions. Interestingly, we are not asked about time for speakers.
Question 10 is the first chance colleagues have to provide comments. We suggest you focus on changes that would increase rather than reduce democracy as well as support participation and reduce stress.
This could include improvements to the electronic voting system, a change of chairperson e.g. every two hours to avoid fatigue, a more accessible system for indicating points of order, reducing speaking times for proposers and other speakers in the standing orders, and reducing speaking times for presenting sections of the Congress Report, General Secretary and President.
Speeding up voting and reducing speaking times would allow more business to be discussed. You may have other ideas.


